DISQUS

DISQUS Hello! /var/log/mind is using DISQUS, a powerful comment system, to manage its comments. Learn more.

Community Page

/var/log/mind

Dhananjay Nene’s free (as in free speech) opinions on all things related to Software Engineering
Jump to original thread »
Author

My first impressions of Google Knol

Started by Dhananjay Nene · 11 months ago

Google just launched “Knol” today (announced here on their blog). Back in january, I had written up a blog post - Will the knol be a knowall ?, so I was immediately curious to get a first hand experience. Here’s my fresh off the oven first impressions of ... Continue reading »

3 comments

  • I've used TeamWiki (a wiki based CMS) internally and I felt it is good. My opinion is also same as you that Wiki is enough for enterprises.

    But, Knol may have an edge over wiki because of Google' search power!
  • Yes, but who owns your articles - you or google?
  • Dhananjay, few things.

    - The reason Knol is called as authoritative because others can rate and comment on articles, which is not possible with Wikis.
    - Knol has content about almost everything, try searching for it. Most of it is imported from Wikipedia though.
    - The license for the content is Creative Commons, which means content is owned by author and cannot be used for commercial purposes. This is same as Wikipedia.
    - Unlike Wikipedia, Knol tries to put in some well formed structure around the content. It essentially tries to incorporate all the essential elements we use while publishing a paper.
    - Ability to have multiple articles on same topic is a very good feature as against Wikipedia. This was one very big drawback with Wikipedia, you could either edit existing article or have to pick article name so that it doesn't coincide with existing article. This is very essential feature for lot of controversial topics.

    Knol is a competition for Wikipedia and not for Wikis in general so I don't see any usecase for enterprises internal use.

Add New Comment

Returning? Login